Nobody is allowed to steal my kidneys
Jun. 4th, 2010 03:33 pmJust got off captioning the Ohio senate, where along with various expansions to concealed carry by convicts they decided to impose a stricter standard on judges who grant abortions to minors who can't get parental consent, requiring the judges to ask whether the minors have been coached and to demand a full explanation of exactly why the minor feels she is ready for an abortion and how well she understands the complications that could ensue. They did this because 92% of judges now grant the minor the abortion.
On the face of it, this sort of seems reasonable -- the language was very "protect this poor child who might not realize what she's doing, or who might be hiding this abortion from a parent who would love her anyway" -- but ultimately it's a twisted view of what is going on. In order to go before a court in this type of case, you have to hire a lawyer, file several briefs, and wait a while. Probably you've already thought about it. You've certainly already talked to a lot of adults, like your lawyer and your doctor and whoever is going to ultimately perform the abortion if granted. Of course most judges are going to grant it -- you wouldn't be at this point if it wasn't really, really important to you. And if there was any chance your parents were going to be on your side, you'd have gone with that.
Abortion is unfortunate and can have medical and emotional complications. That's a reality I'm happy to acknowledge. But for god's sake, childbirth can have medical and emotional complications, especially if you're not ready for it. If you are, for instance, 14. Giving a baby up for adoption has emotional complications. Raising a child has emotional complications. Ultimately, of these scenarios, I would suggest that a first-trimester abortion is less emotionally complicated and less medically dangerous than any other option. By the time you get to abortion, the tragic and emotionally upsetting thing has already happened. It's too late. Why are we putting these kids through this?
On the face of it, this sort of seems reasonable -- the language was very "protect this poor child who might not realize what she's doing, or who might be hiding this abortion from a parent who would love her anyway" -- but ultimately it's a twisted view of what is going on. In order to go before a court in this type of case, you have to hire a lawyer, file several briefs, and wait a while. Probably you've already thought about it. You've certainly already talked to a lot of adults, like your lawyer and your doctor and whoever is going to ultimately perform the abortion if granted. Of course most judges are going to grant it -- you wouldn't be at this point if it wasn't really, really important to you. And if there was any chance your parents were going to be on your side, you'd have gone with that.
Abortion is unfortunate and can have medical and emotional complications. That's a reality I'm happy to acknowledge. But for god's sake, childbirth can have medical and emotional complications, especially if you're not ready for it. If you are, for instance, 14. Giving a baby up for adoption has emotional complications. Raising a child has emotional complications. Ultimately, of these scenarios, I would suggest that a first-trimester abortion is less emotionally complicated and less medically dangerous than any other option. By the time you get to abortion, the tragic and emotionally upsetting thing has already happened. It's too late. Why are we putting these kids through this?