Get with the program, Neo-Freudians
Jul. 1st, 2007 11:43 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
rinueMy main trouble with Freudianism is that it ignores evolution in favor of solipsism: all motivations and experiences are internal and tied to early individual ego formation, not the result of thousands of years of species development. I forgive Freud himself; given the time in which he was working, his oversight is excusable, and given his patients, it's reasonable that he'd view human beings as basically not functioning - whereas evolution says the opposite, says that on balance we're the most successful way for us to be.
For instance, if we enjoy sex, it's not an attempt to ingest the other and in so doing own them, or a means of replacing the oral satisfaction of nursing (regardless of whether we used a bottle instead of a breast) - it's because our nerves and brain chemistry are arranged in a way that encourages us through pleasure to have more sex. Sex = procreation chance = evolutionary advantage and the continuation of the human race.
I mean, jeeze, guys. There are nerves in places other than the brain, and we didn't individually decide to put them there.
Ciro and I have kind of a [somewhere between a competition, an inside joke, and a hobby] going on where we try to find the most impenetrable or unncessary example of gradspeak. My current lead example is "his inedia is doubled by an even more intransigent aphonia*." Anybody out there have a favorite academic convolution?
*Translation: He is starving and won't talk.
For instance, if we enjoy sex, it's not an attempt to ingest the other and in so doing own them, or a means of replacing the oral satisfaction of nursing (regardless of whether we used a bottle instead of a breast) - it's because our nerves and brain chemistry are arranged in a way that encourages us through pleasure to have more sex. Sex = procreation chance = evolutionary advantage and the continuation of the human race.
I mean, jeeze, guys. There are nerves in places other than the brain, and we didn't individually decide to put them there.
Ciro and I have kind of a [somewhere between a competition, an inside joke, and a hobby] going on where we try to find the most impenetrable or unncessary example of gradspeak. My current lead example is "his inedia is doubled by an even more intransigent aphonia*." Anybody out there have a favorite academic convolution?
*Translation: He is starving and won't talk.
